2025 Paint Price Comparison: Sherwin-Williams Versus Benjamin Moore
Selecting premium paint involves more than choosing a color. Homeowners seek finishes that endure, apply smoothly, and deliver reliable outcomes. Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore stand out for their superior quality, yet they vary in pricing, composition, and effectiveness. Grasping these distinctions enables informed decisions that match project objectives and financial plans.
Detailed Project Cost Analysis
Typical Price Ranges
- Basic applications: $40 to $55 per gallon
- Standard applications: $60 to $80 per gallon
- Premium applications: $85 to $120 per gallon
Core Components Included
Premium paints incorporate advanced pigments and resins for vibrant hues and strong adhesion. They feature tailored finishes for interior walls, trim, and exterior elements. These formulations ensure extended color stability and resistance to cleaning. Coverage proves uniform, often needing only one or two coats for full opacity.
Additional Expenses
Custom designer palettes and unique textures add to the total. Primers and preparatory materials increase costs for optimal adhesion. Professional tools like high-end brushes and rollers contribute further. Engaging certified applicators elevates the price through skilled labor.
Influences on Total Expenditure
| Factor | Influence on Cost | Specific Instances |
|---|---|---|
| Paint Category | Rises with enhanced resilience or specialized blends | Weatherproof exterior formulas demand higher investment |
| Sheen Variety | Elevated for glossier surfaces | Satin and semi-gloss utilize costlier compounds |
| Area Requirements | Determines volume of paint needed | Bold shades or rough textures require additional layers |
| Workforce | Fluctuates by location and intricacy | Experts bill $2 to $6 per square foot |
In-Depth Brand Evaluation
Each company provides diverse options, with variations in expense and functionality tied to specific product lines.
Sherwin-Williams Profile
Sherwin-Williams earns acclaim for contractor-oriented products and widespread distribution. Professionals value its reliability and accessibility. Key interior offerings encompass Emerald, Duration Home, and SuperPaint.
- Emerald Interior: Priced at $85 to $110 per gallon, this line excels in coverage, antimicrobial properties, and robustness for busy spaces.
- Duration Home: Valued at $70 to $85 per gallon, it merges efficiency and affordability for everyday interior surfaces.
- SuperPaint: Ranging from $55 to $70 per gallon, it delivers dependable opacity and economy for routine home tasks.
These paints facilitate quick application with minimal layers. Uniform curing and even results minimize time spent, thereby lowering overall labor expenses.
Benjamin Moore Profile
Benjamin Moore establishes itself as a luxury choice with innovative pigmentation and dense color saturation. Prominent interior series include Aura, Regal Select, and Ben.
- Aura Interior: At $90 to $120 per gallon, it boasts intense pigmentation, built-in priming, and exceptional scrub resistance.
- Regal Select: From $65 to $80 per gallon, it combines longevity with effortless spreading at a balanced rate.
- Ben Interior: Between $45 and $60 per gallon, this accessible option upholds solid opacity and refined appearance.
Homeowners drawn to visual excellence favor these paints. The company's precise hue replication guarantees uniformity, ideal for intricate decorative efforts.
Expense Breakdown by Application
| Application | Sherwin-Williams Estimate | Benjamin Moore Estimate |
|---|---|---|
| Interior room walls | $150 to $300 | $160 to $320 |
| Exterior refresh (1,000 square feet) | $1,800 to $3,200 | $1,900 to $3,400 |
| Cabinet renewal (one set) | $300 to $600 | $350 to $650 |
| Room trim and doors | $120 to $220 | $130 to $240 |
Per-gallon variances seem modest, but they accumulate in extensive undertakings influenced by adhesion efficiency, prep work, and personnel. Sherwin-Williams frequently provides promotions via outlets, whereas Benjamin Moore maintains steady rates.
Expert Application Versus Self-Directed Efforts
Professional services append $2 to $6 per square foot for labor. Advantages include accuracy, efficiency, and guaranteed performance. Self-directed painting reduces outlays but demands appropriate equipment, thorough prep, and careful execution.
- Opt for experts when: Tackling expansive or multi-area jobs, repairing substrates, or applying sophisticated sheens that necessitate expertise for flawless execution.
- Choose self-directed for: Compact spaces, feature walls, or minor refreshes where exactitude matters less.
Step-by-Step Project Preparation
- Select hues: Apply test patches to surfaces and observe under varied illumination conditions.
- Determine sheen: Opt for matte, eggshell, satin, or semi-gloss according to maintenance and wear demands.
- Prepare substrates: Wash, abrade, and mend walls to promote adhesion.
- Time the work: Permit sufficient intervals for coat drying and adjust for moisture levels in outdoor settings.
- Allocate funds: Include allowances for base coats, implements, and unforeseen adjustments.
Selecting the Optimal Paint for Lasting Results
Premium paints justify their price through superior longevity and reduced maintenance. Sherwin-Williams suits practical, cost-conscious projects with broad availability. Benjamin Moore elevates designs with unmatched vibrancy and precision. Evaluate your priorities—durability, aesthetics, or budget—to select the brand that maximizes value for your home improvement.
Common Queries Addressed
Why Invest in Premium Over Basic Paints?
Superior paints employ refined pigments and binders for deeper tones, superior opacity, and extended service life. Fewer applications often balance the initial premium, yielding long-term savings.
Optimal Number of Coats for Superior Outcomes?
Two layers typically achieve uniform results. Intense colors or new surfaces benefit from a base coat followed by two finishes. Specialists assess each area to recommend the precise approach.
Cost Savings with Handymen Versus Specialists?
Handymen offer lower rates for modest tasks or repairs, yet certified professionals bring expertise for complex or sizable endeavors. For outdoor or furniture applications, specialists prove more economical overall.
Choosing Between Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore?
Examine swatches for texture and spread. Sherwin-Williams provides easier access and savings opportunities, while Benjamin Moore delivers profound coloration and refined options.
Anticipated Unseen Expenses in Painting?
Repairs, base layers, equipment, and shade tweaks frequently arise. Extended labor for extra applications or fixes can also inflate totals.
Achieving Expert-Level Finishes at Home?
Meticulous substrate readiness, premium applicators, and deliberate layering transform results. Engaging seasoned applicators guarantees symmetry, crisp edges, and enduring quality.
